Thanksgiving is one of the most recognized holidays in the United States, a day celebrated by millions with family gatherings, festive meals, and expressions of gratitude. The holiday’s continued observance speaks to its deeply entrenched place in American culture and the many meanings it holds for different groups within society. Yet, as with many traditions, the question of why we still celebrate Thanksgiving is a layered and complicated one, particularly given its complex historical roots and the issues that continue to surround it today.
For some, Thanksgiving is a joyful occasion that marks the importance of family, gratitude, and togetherness. For others, it is a day of reflection, resistance, and mourning—a reminder of the painful history of colonization and its lasting impact on Native American communities. To truly understand why we still celebrate Thanksgiving, we must look at its origins, its transformation over the centuries, and the way it is viewed through both celebratory and critical lenses.
In this article, we will explore the reasons why Thanksgiving continues to be celebrated in the United States, considering its historical, cultural, and social dimensions. We will delve into the perspectives that support its continued observance, as well as those that question the holiday’s legacy. By the end, we hope to offer a comprehensive understanding of why Thanksgiving remains an enduring part of American life.
The Roots of Thanksgiving: A Contested History
The history of Thanksgiving is often taught as a simple story of friendship between Native Americans and early European settlers. However, the full history of the holiday is far more complex, involving the interplay of indigenous cultures, colonialism, and the gradual shaping of the American national identity.
1. The “First Thanksgiving” Myth: A Simplified Narrative
The commonly accepted origin of Thanksgiving is the 1621 feast held by the Pilgrims at Plymouth Colony in present-day Massachusetts. This event, often referred to as the “First Thanksgiving,” was a celebration of the Pilgrims’ successful harvest, attended by both the settlers and the Wampanoag people. In popular culture, the story is framed as a harmonious occasion in which the indigenous Wampanoag tribe helped the struggling Pilgrims survive their first year by providing them with food and agricultural knowledge.
However, this narrative is overly simplistic and omits much of the more complicated and painful history that followed. While the first feast was a moment of cooperation, the years that followed saw a dramatic shift in the relationship between settlers and indigenous peoples. The Wampanoag, led by Chief Massasoit, would later face increasing pressure from the colonists, who expanded their settlements and encroached upon native lands. This expansion ultimately led to conflicts, loss of land, and a long history of violence and displacement for Native Americans.
The notion of a “peaceful” and “unified” Thanksgiving feast obscures the ongoing consequences of colonization. For many Native Americans, the celebration of Thanksgiving represents the beginning of centuries of loss, violence, and dispossession. Thus, while the “First Thanksgiving” story is central to American tradition, it must be contextualized within the broader and more painful history of settler-colonialism.
2. Native American Perspectives: Thanksgiving as a Day of Mourning
For many Native Americans, Thanksgiving is not a celebration, but a day of mourning. The arrival of European settlers marked the beginning of a long and often tragic history for indigenous peoples. Colonization brought violence, disease, and the forced displacement of native communities from their ancestral lands. Over the centuries, treaties were broken, cultural practices were suppressed, and entire communities were displaced or wiped out.
As a result, many Native Americans view Thanksgiving as a reminder of the systemic and ongoing challenges faced by their communities. The 1621 feast, while a brief moment of cooperation, was also the beginning of a larger, more destructive process that led to the erasure of indigenous cultures and ways of life.
In recent years, there has been a growing movement among Native Americans to use Thanksgiving as an opportunity to educate the public about indigenous history, to protest historical injustices, and to reclaim the narrative of their peoples. Native groups across the U.S. hold “National Day of Mourning” events on Thanksgiving Day, where they gather to remember the impact of colonization and to honor their ancestors.
Why Do We Still Celebrate Thanksgiving? Multiple Perspectives
Despite the holiday’s painful history for Native Americans, Thanksgiving is still widely celebrated across the United States. The reasons for this continued observance are diverse, reflecting both the enduring aspects of the holiday’s original intent and the evolving ways in which it has been interpreted over time.
1. The Spirit of Gratitude and Family
For many people, Thanksgiving has come to symbolize an opportunity to express gratitude for the blessings of the past year. It is a time to reflect on the things one is thankful for—whether it be family, good health, personal achievements, or the simple joys of life. As a national holiday, it has become a time to pause and appreciate the things that are often taken for granted in the rush of everyday life.
In many American households, Thanksgiving is a family-oriented holiday. Relatives travel from near and far to gather around a shared meal, typically featuring turkey, stuffing, and various side dishes. The tradition of coming together with family members fosters a sense of connection and belonging, and the act of sharing a meal is seen as a way to strengthen familial bonds.
In this sense, Thanksgiving represents more than just a historical event—it has evolved into a holiday that celebrates human connection, love, and appreciation for the good in life. For many, this is the primary reason why the holiday continues to be important.
2. Thanksgiving as a Time of Reflection and Togetherness
In a world where individuals are increasingly caught up in busy work schedules, the commercialization of holidays, and the digital demands of daily life, Thanksgiving offers a rare moment for people to step back and reflect. For many, the day provides a sense of respite, a time to pause and focus on what truly matters—family, relationships, and community.
This pause in daily routines fosters a sense of togetherness, and it is often cited as one of the main reasons why Thanksgiving is still celebrated. People look forward to reuniting with loved ones, reminiscing about shared memories, and creating new ones. For some, this time of reflection is also a spiritual practice—whether through prayer, meditation, or simply taking time to appreciate life’s blessings.
3. The Role of Food in Thanksgiving Tradition
The Thanksgiving meal is a central tradition in American culture, and its importance cannot be overstated. The iconic dishes associated with Thanksgiving, such as turkey, mashed potatoes, cranberry sauce, and pumpkin pie, have become symbols of abundance, comfort, and tradition.
For many people, preparing and sharing a meal together is an integral part of the celebration. It is a time to bond over the act of cooking, share recipes passed down through generations, and express gratitude through the care and effort put into preparing food. The Thanksgiving meal serves as a reminder of the importance of nurturing relationships and taking time to care for one another, and this has made the holiday deeply meaningful for millions of Americans.
4. Commercialization and the National Economy
Thanksgiving is also intertwined with the commercial and economic cycles of the nation. In addition to being a time for family, it marks the unofficial start of the holiday shopping season in the U.S. Retailers heavily promote Black Friday sales, and many families take part in this consumer-driven tradition. This aspect of Thanksgiving has led some to view it less as a solemn occasion of reflection and more as a prelude to the commercialized holiday season.
While the commercialization of Thanksgiving has drawn criticism, especially from those who believe it detracts from the true meaning of the holiday, it has undoubtedly become an economic driving force. For some, the increased consumer activity and the sense of excitement that comes with it are part of the holiday experience.
5. Thanksgiving as a Symbol of National Unity
Despite its complicated history, Thanksgiving has often been viewed as a symbol of national unity. In the 19th century, President Abraham Lincoln proclaimed the first national day of thanksgiving during the Civil War, calling for Americans to give thanks for the blessings of the nation even amidst the strife and division of war. Lincoln’s call was an effort to foster a sense of collective purpose and national healing.
Since then, Thanksgiving has continued to serve as a day that brings Americans together, regardless of regional, cultural, or political differences. While the holiday is still not without its criticisms, it remains an opportunity for citizens to express collective gratitude and reflect on shared values. For many, this sense of unity is a key reason why Thanksgiving is still celebrated.
Criticisms of Thanksgiving: Reconciliation and Resistance
While Thanksgiving continues to be a beloved holiday for many, it is not without its criticisms, particularly from Native American groups and others who feel that the holiday fails to adequately address the historical injustices that it represents. As mentioned earlier, Thanksgiving has long been seen by some as a day of mourning rather than celebration.
In recent years, efforts have been made to reframe Thanksgiving, both within Native American communities and among those who are seeking greater cultural sensitivity. The movement to rename the holiday or to promote alternative observances, such as Indigenous Peoples’ Day, has gained traction. These alternative celebrations seek to honor indigenous peoples and their contributions to the nation, as well as to raise awareness about the continuing struggles of Native communities.
Some advocates argue that Thanksgiving should be reimagined as a time for learning about Native American history, recognizing indigenous rights, and acknowledging the legacy of colonization. The celebration of Thanksgiving, they believe, should be accompanied by a deeper reckoning with the injustices faced by Native peoples.
Conclusion: Embracing the Complexity of Thanksgiving
Thanksgiving is a holiday that is fraught with complexities. It is a day of gratitude, family, and community, but it is also a reminder of the painful history of colonization and the ongoing struggles faced by Native Americans. While some celebrate Thanksgiving as a time for reflection and togetherness, others use it as a moment to raise awareness and protest the injustices that the holiday symbolizes.
The question of why we still celebrate Thanksgiving is not easily answered, as it depends on one’s perspective, cultural background, and historical understanding. For many, it is a deeply meaningful occasion that fosters connection and gratitude. For others, it is a day to confront the painful truths of the past and advocate for a more inclusive and equitable future.
Ultimately, the continued celebration of Thanksgiving is a reflection of the broader complexities of American identity, history, and culture. As long as the holiday endures, it will remain a space for both celebration and critique, for remembrance and resistance, as we navigate the ever-evolving story of the United States.
Related topics:
What Do Jews Eat on Thanksgiving?