As Canada’s two-month GST/HST tax holiday draws to a close this weekend, reactions from both businesses and consumers are mixed, leaving some to question whether the temporary measure lived up to its promises.
Launched in December 2024 as part of the Tax Break for All Canadians Act, the holiday was designed to relieve Canadians by removing federal taxes from a range of essential goods, from groceries to books and even dining out. The break, however, has elicited differing views on its effectiveness, and its impact remains unclear, with economic data still rolling in.
Sylvain Charlebois, senior director of Dalhousie University’s Agri-Foods Analytics Lab, observed that the food service sector seemed to benefit more from the tax holiday than the grocery industry. He noted that restaurants saw a boost in traffic during the typically slow months of January and February, as the tax break encouraged more people to dine out.
Yet, while some sectors saw a slight uptick, others struggled with the temporary policy. According to Moneris, Canada’s largest payment processor, transactions in the restaurant industry fell by 6% year-over-year between December 14 and January 15, with fast food showing declines of 1% and 8% in transaction numbers and size, respectively. Nationwide, total spending also saw a 4% dip during the same period.
For business owners, especially in the food service and retail sectors, the implementation of the tax holiday added complexity without always yielding the desired results. Many reported that while the policy aimed to stimulate spending, its short-lived nature created confusion and extra work.
As the program ends, calls are growing from some quarters to make the GST/HST exemption permanent for certain goods, especially food items. Sylvain Charlebois emphasized that while the measure had some merit, its temporary nature might have undercut its effectiveness, particularly when it came to grocery prices.
For some, the tax holiday failed to provide the relief they were hoping for. Canadian shoppers were divided in their feedback, with some expressing that it didn’t significantly alter their purchasing behavior, while others welcomed the small savings and considered it a helpful nudge for dining out.
Overall, the GST/HST holiday’s legacy is still up for debate, with mixed reviews from consumers and businesses alike. Whether it was a boon or bust will depend largely on who you ask—some see it as a short-term gain that could have long-term implications, while others hope for a more permanent solution to help with affordability in the future.
Related topics:
Is Valentine’s Day More Than Just a Commercialized Holiday?
Maldives’ “World’s Biggest Getaway” Campaign Captivates Global Audience
Presidents Day: History, Meaning, and What’s Closed in California