Thanksgiving is one of the most widely celebrated holidays in the United States, bringing families and friends together to enjoy food, express gratitude, and reflect on shared history. While the tradition of giving thanks dates back to the early days of American history, the timing of the celebration—specifically its occurrence in November—has roots that span multiple centuries and intertwine with the complex cultural, historical, and agricultural landscape of early America. In this article, we will explore why we celebrate Thanksgiving in November, delving into its historical origins, the evolution of the holiday, and the reasons for its placement in the fall.
The Origins of Thanksgiving: A Feast of Gratitude
The origins of Thanksgiving in the United States are often traced back to the early 17th century when English Pilgrims, seeking religious freedom, established a colony in Plymouth, Massachusetts, in 1620. The settlers, known as Pilgrims, experienced severe hardships during their first winter in the New World, facing harsh weather conditions, food shortages, and diseases. However, in the spring of 1621, they were introduced to Native American tribes, particularly the Wampanoag people, who taught them how to grow crops such as corn and squash and how to hunt local game.
In the fall of 1621, after a successful harvest, the Pilgrims and the Wampanoag came together for a feast to celebrate the abundance of food and to give thanks for the help and cooperation of the Native people. This event, often regarded as the “First Thanksgiving,” lasted for three days and featured a feast of wildfowl, venison, corn, and other foods native to the region. Though the exact nature of the food and festivities is not fully known, the gathering marked a moment of mutual respect and cooperation between the two groups. The Pilgrims considered the event a time of giving thanks to God for their survival, while the Wampanoag celebrated their harvest and the peace they had established with the newcomers.
While this 1621 feast is often mythologized as the origin of the Thanksgiving holiday, it was not immediately recognized as an official or recurring holiday. The practice of holding feasts of thanks for bountiful harvests existed in many early American colonies, but the formal establishment of a national Thanksgiving Day would take centuries to develop.
The Evolution of Thanksgiving: From Regional Celebration to National Holiday
The idea of a Thanksgiving holiday continued to evolve over the centuries, with various states and colonies observing days of thanks at different times of the year. However, the practice of celebrating Thanksgiving in November did not become widely established until the 19th century. A number of key events and cultural shifts led to the eventual establishment of Thanksgiving as a fixed holiday in late November.
The Influence of Harvest Festivals
Before Thanksgiving became a formalized holiday, many communities in colonial America celebrated harvest festivals in the fall to give thanks for the agricultural abundance of the year. These festivals were often held in late autumn, after the harvest had been completed, as the bounty of crops would be gathered and stored for the winter months. The fall harvest, particularly in November, marked the time when communities could take stock of their food supplies, celebrate the fruits of their labor, and offer gratitude for the successful growing season.
Though these harvest festivals varied from region to region, the themes of thanksgiving, communal sharing, and feasting were consistent throughout early American life. These festivals mirrored the seasonal cycle of agricultural labor, and thus the late fall period became the natural time for such celebrations.
George Washington and the Early Proclamations of Thanksgiving
The concept of a national Thanksgiving Day first gained significant momentum during the early years of the United States. President George Washington issued the first national proclamation of Thanksgiving in 1789. His declaration was rooted in the desire to unite the young nation after the tumult of the Revolutionary War and to recognize the divine guidance and providence that had supported the fledgling republic.
In his proclamation, Washington called for a “Day of Public Thanksgiving and Prayer,” recommending that Americans come together to express gratitude to God for the nation’s achievements and the safety of its people. However, Washington’s call was not for an annual holiday; instead, it was a one-time observance to promote national unity and reflection.
While Washington’s proclamation did not set a specific date for Thanksgiving, it laid the groundwork for the future observance of the holiday. Over the next several decades, various states and regions continued to hold their own Thanksgiving observances, but there was no consistency in timing.
Sarah Josepha Hale and the Campaign for a National Holiday
One of the most influential figures in the establishment of Thanksgiving as a national holiday was Sarah Josepha Hale, a prominent writer and editor. Hale, who is perhaps best known for writing the nursery rhyme “Mary Had a Little Lamb,” was a passionate advocate for Thanksgiving. In 1827, Hale began a decades-long campaign to establish Thanksgiving as an official holiday. She used her position as editor of the magazine Godey’s Lady’s Book to publish essays and editorials advocating for a national day of thanks.
Hale’s vision for Thanksgiving was one of national unity, bringing together all Americans, regardless of region or background, to celebrate and give thanks for the country’s prosperity. In her writings, she specifically argued for the holiday to be observed in the fall, when harvests were typically complete and the community could celebrate the fruits of the year’s labor.
Hale’s persistence paid off in 1863, when President Abraham Lincoln, during the height of the Civil War, issued a proclamation establishing Thanksgiving as a national holiday. Lincoln declared that the final Thursday of November would be a day of “Thanksgiving and Praise to our beneficent Father who dwelleth in the Heavens.”
Lincoln’s proclamation resonated deeply with Americans, who were experiencing the trauma of war and needed a moment of unity and reflection. By setting the day in November, Lincoln ensured that the holiday would coincide with the end of the harvest season, aligning it with the agricultural traditions that had long been celebrated. It also allowed families to gather before the harsh winter months set in.
From that point on, Thanksgiving became a national holiday celebrated on the last Thursday of November.
The Shift to the Fourth Thursday: FDR and the Debate Over Timing
For much of the 19th and early 20th centuries, Thanksgiving was celebrated on the last Thursday in November, as designated by Lincoln’s 1863 proclamation. However, during the Great Depression, the timing of the holiday came into question. In 1939, President Franklin D. Roosevelt, seeking to extend the holiday shopping season and boost consumer spending, moved Thanksgiving up one week to the third Thursday of November.
The move, intended to benefit businesses, was met with significant opposition. Many Americans were confused, and a number of states continued to observe Thanksgiving on the last Thursday of November. This division between the third and last Thursday caused significant disruption for families and retailers, leading to widespread disagreement about the new date.
In 1941, after two years of confusion and debate, Congress passed a law officially setting Thanksgiving Day as the fourth Thursday of November. Roosevelt signed the bill into law, and since then, Thanksgiving has been celebrated on the fourth Thursday of November each year.
Why November? The Agricultural and Seasonal Context
The timing of Thanksgiving in November is closely tied to the agricultural cycle of North America. In the past, November was a natural time to celebrate the harvest for several reasons:
End of the Harvest Season: November falls at the conclusion of the autumn harvest in the Northern Hemisphere. By this time, the majority of crops, including grains, fruits, and vegetables, have been gathered. Farmers would typically have their food supplies ready for the winter, making it an ideal time for a feast to give thanks for a successful growing season.
Before the Harsh Winter: Historically, the winter months were difficult for many families, especially those in agrarian communities. The cold, shorter days meant limited food availability, and traveling was often more dangerous. Holding a Thanksgiving feast before the cold set in allowed families to gather and celebrate before the harsh winter months.
Symbolic of Reflection and Gratitude: In many cultures, fall and the end of the harvest are seen as times of reflection. The abundance of food symbolizes not just the physical harvest but also the fruits of hard labor and preparation for the future. Thanksgiving, then, represents a time to reflect on what has been accomplished and express gratitude for the blessings of the year.
Cultural Significance of Fall: The fall season holds deep cultural significance in many Native American communities, as it marks the end of the harvest and the preparation for winter. Many Indigenous peoples, like the Wampanoag who participated in the 1621 feast with the Pilgrims, traditionally held ceremonies of thanksgiving after the harvest, making the timing of Thanksgiving in November not only practical but culturally resonant.
Thanksgiving as a Modern Celebration: A Time for Family, Gratitude, and Community
Today, Thanksgiving is a multifaceted celebration, deeply ingrained in American culture. For many, the holiday represents a time for family to come together, share a meal, and reflect on what they are thankful for. While the historical and agricultural roots of the holiday remain important, Thanksgiving has evolved into a cultural tradition that includes parades, sports events, and other forms of entertainment.
The timing of Thanksgiving in November, however, continues to resonate. For many Americans, the holiday offers a welcome pause before the start of the busy winter holiday season, providing an opportunity to connect with loved ones and give thanks for the blessings of the past year.
Conclusion: The Significance of November in Thanksgiving
Thanksgiving in November is the result of centuries of cultural, agricultural, and historical developments. Its timing aligns with the natural agricultural cycle, marking the end of the harvest season and the beginning of winter preparations. From its early roots in Native American and colonial traditions to its formalization as a national holiday by President Lincoln, Thanksgiving has evolved into a celebration that is both personal and communal.
Today, Thanksgiving serves as a reminder of the importance of family, gratitude, and reflection, and its timing in late November is both a practical and symbolic choice, rooted in the cycles of nature, history, and culture. As we gather with loved ones to give thanks, we are also participating in a long-standing tradition that has been shaped by the past, but remains relevant and meaningful in the present.
Related topics:
Where Can I See the Thanksgiving Balloons Blown Up?