The first Thanksgiving, often depicted as a harmonious feast shared between the Pilgrims and Native Americans, holds a special place in American history. It is traditionally viewed as a time to celebrate the harvest, express gratitude, and strengthen bonds between different groups. However, the true reasons for the first Thanksgiving are complex and rooted in the historical, cultural, and political dynamics of the early 17th century. This article explores the origins of the first Thanksgiving, examining the social, economic, and political contexts that led to its celebration, as well as the long-term implications for both the Pilgrims and the Indigenous peoples involved.
The Arrival of the Pilgrims: Context Leading to the First Thanksgiving
In 1620, a group of English Puritans, known as the Pilgrims, set sail from Plymouth, England, aboard the Mayflower in search of religious freedom. They landed on the shores of what is now Massachusetts, far north of their intended destination in the Virginia Colony. The harsh conditions of the new land—unfamiliar climate, scarce food supplies, and difficult terrain—put the survival of the Pilgrims in jeopardy. By the time winter had set in, nearly half of the original group had perished due to illness and starvation.
The Pilgrims, struggling to establish a self-sustaining colony, faced immense challenges. The prospect of starvation loomed large, and they desperately needed help. This is where the Native Americans, particularly the Wampanoag people, came into play.
The Role of Native Americans: Wampanoag Tribe and the Pilgrims
Before the Pilgrims arrived, the land they settled on was already inhabited by Indigenous peoples. The Wampanoag Nation, a group of Algonquian-speaking people, lived in the region. They had a rich culture, sophisticated agricultural practices, and a deep understanding of the local environment. Their way of life was based on a complex relationship with nature, which included hunting, fishing, gathering, and agriculture.
The Wampanoag had already faced their own challenges before the arrival of the Pilgrims. In the early 1600s, European diseases such as smallpox had devastated many Native populations along the eastern seaboard. In fact, the Wampanoag people had seen their numbers drastically reduced, which made them vulnerable to the encroachment of settlers.
In 1621, a key figure in this interaction emerged—Massasoit, the leader of the Wampanoag Confederacy. Realizing that his people faced threats from rival tribes and European colonists, Massasoit entered into an alliance with the Pilgrims. This alliance was partly motivated by the shared threat of other Indigenous groups and the Pilgrims’ potential access to European trade goods. The Pilgrims, in turn, relied on the Wampanoag for guidance, knowledge of the land, and help with food sources.
The First Thanksgiving: A Celebration of Cooperation and Survival
The famous 1621 feast, traditionally considered the first Thanksgiving, was not the single event it is often depicted as today, but rather part of an ongoing process of cooperation between the Pilgrims and the Wampanoag people. The “feast” was a multi-day event that marked the Pilgrims’ successful harvest after a difficult year. It was a celebration of survival—both the Pilgrims’ survival through the harsh winter and the Wampanoag’s assistance in providing them with crucial food sources.
During this time, the Pilgrims had been introduced to several agricultural techniques by the Wampanoag, including how to plant corn with fish as fertilizer, how to catch fish, and how to grow beans, squash, and other crops that were essential to the colony’s survival. In return, the Pilgrims offered the Wampanoag gifts such as beads, weapons, and other items they had acquired through trade with the English.
The 1621 feast included a wide array of foods, many of which were native to the region. The menu likely consisted of venison, wildfowl (turkey, ducks, and geese), corn, beans, squash, and shellfish. It is important to note that the feast was not just a one-time event. The Pilgrims and the Wampanoag continued their relationship over the next few years, although tensions would eventually rise, leading to conflicts such as King Philip’s War in the 1670s.
The Pilgrims’ Perspective: Gratitude and Religious Observance
For the Pilgrims, the first Thanksgiving was a deeply spiritual occasion. They were separatists who had fled religious persecution in England. Having arrived in the New World with the intention of establishing a community where they could practice their religion freely, they were deeply committed to gratitude for what they saw as divine providence. To the Pilgrims, the feast was an expression of thanks to God for delivering them through their trials.
In their view, the successful harvest and survival in a new land were clear signs of God’s favor. They had arrived in Plymouth with little more than their faith, and now they had crops to harvest and a community to build. This religious aspect of the feast reflects the Puritan mindset, where both hardship and prosperity were seen as a reflection of God’s will. The Pilgrims’ celebration was thus as much about religious devotion and thanksgiving as it was about acknowledging the help they had received from the Wampanoag people.
The Wampanoag Perspective: Strategic Alliance and Cultural Exchange
For the Wampanoag, the 1621 gathering was not an act of pure generosity, but rather a strategic move in the complex political landscape of the region. Massasoit and his people were faced with increasing pressure from rival tribes, such as the Narragansett, and the expansion of European settlers. By forging an alliance with the Pilgrims, Massasoit hoped to gain access to European trade goods and military support against his enemies.
However, the Wampanoag were not simply helping out of political expediency. The relationship with the Pilgrims allowed for cultural exchange, particularly in the area of agriculture. The Wampanoag shared knowledge that would ensure the survival of the colony, which, in turn, would help secure their position in the region.
Despite the alliance, there was a certain level of mistrust between the two groups. The Pilgrims and the Wampanoag had different worldviews, particularly when it came to land ownership and territorial boundaries. The Pilgrims believed in private property and saw the land as something to be cultivated, while the Wampanoag had a more communal view of land use. Over time, the cultural and political differences between the two groups would lead to tensions, which would ultimately result in violence.
The Evolution of Thanksgiving: From Feast to National Holiday
The first Thanksgiving in 1621 was a brief and relatively peaceful moment in the midst of a long history of interaction between Native Americans and European settlers. In the centuries following the event, Thanksgiving would evolve into a national holiday, celebrated across the United States. However, the historical context surrounding Thanksgiving would change dramatically, particularly in the 19th and 20th centuries.
Thanksgiving became an official holiday in 1863, when President Abraham Lincoln proclaimed it a national day of thanks during the Civil War. Lincoln’s proclamation was influenced by the efforts of Sarah Josepha Hale, a prominent writer and editor, who campaigned for the establishment of a national Thanksgiving holiday. Her efforts culminated in Lincoln’s decision to set aside the last Thursday in November as a day of national thanksgiving.
Over time, Thanksgiving became more commercialized and secularized, with the focus shifting away from the original religious and political significance of the holiday. The Pilgrims’ relationship with the Native Americans also became increasingly romanticized, with the emphasis placed on the notion of harmony and mutual respect. This narrative, however, glosses over the more complicated and often painful history of colonialism, displacement, and violence experienced by Indigenous peoples in the centuries that followed the first Thanksgiving.
The Native American Perspective on Thanksgiving
For many Native Americans, Thanksgiving is a reminder of the complex and painful history of European colonization. While the first Thanksgiving in 1621 was a time of cooperation and exchange, it marked the beginning of a period of displacement, violence, and cultural erosion for Indigenous peoples across North America. The arrival of Europeans led to the destruction of Native American societies, the loss of ancestral lands, and the imposition of foreign diseases that decimated Indigenous populations.
As a result, Thanksgiving has become a day of reflection for many Native Americans. Some observe it as a day of mourning, known as the “National Day of Mourning,” to remember the suffering and injustices endured by their ancestors. This day is marked by protests, educational events, and discussions about the need for greater recognition of Native American rights and histories.
Conclusion: The First Thanksgiving and Its Complex Legacy
The first Thanksgiving of 1621 was a celebration of survival, cooperation, and gratitude, but it was also the beginning of a long and complex relationship between Native Americans and European settlers. While the feast was a moment of mutual respect and cultural exchange, it also laid the groundwork for centuries of conflict, colonization, and cultural erasure. Today, Thanksgiving serves as both a time for celebration and reflection, with many Americans recognizing the importance of acknowledging the diverse histories and perspectives that have shaped the nation.
Understanding the true history of Thanksgiving requires a nuanced perspective—one that honors both the cooperation between the Pilgrims and the Wampanoag and the painful legacy of colonialism that followed. By learning about the first Thanksgiving in its full historical context, we can begin to appreciate its complexity and strive toward greater empathy and understanding of Indigenous peoples’ experiences and contributions to American society.
Related topics:
Why Some People Don’t Celebrate Thanksgiving