The story of the first Thanksgiving, traditionally celebrated on the fourth Thursday of November in the United States, has become an iconic symbol of American history and culture. It is often portrayed as a moment of harmony between the Pilgrims and Native Americans, where both groups came together to share a feast after a successful harvest. But how do we know about the first Thanksgiving? What are the historical sources that provide us with insights into this significant event, and how do different perspectives on its meaning shape our understanding today?
This article will delve into the history of the first Thanksgiving, examining the sources that tell the story, the cultural contexts surrounding the event, and how historical interpretations have evolved over time. It will explore how we piece together the information we have, what we know about the people involved, and the historical legacy of this event. By understanding the sources and the complexities of this story, we can appreciate the cultural significance of Thanksgiving in contemporary American society.
The First Thanksgiving: A Historical Context
The story of the first Thanksgiving takes place in the autumn of 1621 in Plymouth, located in present-day Massachusetts. It marks a significant event in the early colonial history of America, where English Pilgrims and members of the Wampanoag tribe came together to celebrate a successful harvest after a difficult first year for the settlers. However, the way this event is remembered today—largely as a peaceful and harmonious gathering—has been shaped by centuries of interpretation, mythmaking, and cultural shifts.
Before we dive into the historical sources that inform us about the first Thanksgiving, it is essential to understand the broader historical context. The Pilgrims, a group of religious separatists, left England in 1620 aboard the Mayflower to seek religious freedom. After a harsh and deadly winter, they formed a relationship with the Wampanoag people, who had been living in the region for thousands of years. This relationship would play a crucial role in the survival of the Pilgrims, who struggled with farming and securing food after their arrival.
In the fall of 1621, the Pilgrims had a successful harvest, and to celebrate, they organized a feast. This event is considered the “First Thanksgiving,” though it was not called that at the time. The Wampanoag, led by Chief Massasoit, were invited to join the feast, marking a moment of cooperation between the two groups. It is estimated that the feast lasted for three days and featured a variety of foods, including wild turkey, venison, corn, beans, and squash.
The event was significant not only for its immediate purpose—celebrating a successful harvest—but also for the relationship it signified between the Pilgrims and the Wampanoag people. However, the lasting legacy of this gathering would evolve over time, influenced by different perspectives and the changing cultural and political landscape of America.
Primary Sources: What We Know About the First Thanksgiving
To understand how we know about the first Thanksgiving, we must turn to the historical sources that have provided information about the event. These sources include written accounts from the time, including letters, diaries, and official records, as well as oral traditions and historical reconstructions. Although there is no single definitive source, a combination of these documents and traditions helps us piece together what likely occurred.
1. Edward Winslow’s Account: “A Journal of the Pilgrims at Plymouth”
One of the most important sources for understanding the first Thanksgiving is the account written by Edward Winslow, one of the Pilgrims who survived the first winter in Plymouth. Winslow’s writings are part of a larger document known as “A Journal of the Pilgrims at Plymouth,” which was first published in 1622. In this journal, Winslow provides a detailed description of the events surrounding the feast.
Winslow’s account offers several key details about the first Thanksgiving. He describes the invitation extended to the Wampanoag people, who arrived with Chief Massasoit and about 90 men. The Pilgrims, according to Winslow, had recently finished harvesting their crops and had enough food to prepare a feast. Winslow also describes how the Wampanoag people contributed to the meal, bringing venison (deer meat) to share with the Pilgrims.
Winslow’s account also provides insight into the interactions between the two groups, noting that the Pilgrims and Wampanoag engaged in friendly discussions and exchanged gifts. The tone of his writing suggests a sense of mutual respect and camaraderie between the two groups, although the complexity of the relationship would become more complicated in the years following the feast.
2. William Bradford’s Account: “Of Plymouth Plantation”
Another crucial source for understanding the first Thanksgiving is the account written by William Bradford, who was the Governor of Plymouth Colony for over 30 years. Bradford’s work, “Of Plymouth Plantation,” is considered one of the most important documents in American colonial history. In his account, Bradford provides details about the challenges the Pilgrims faced during their first year in the New World, including the deaths from disease and the difficulties of farming in unfamiliar terrain.
Bradford’s account also contains references to the interactions between the Pilgrims and the Wampanoag. He notes that the Pilgrims and the Native Americans formed a mutual aid agreement, with the Wampanoag helping the Pilgrims with hunting and agriculture. Bradford emphasizes the importance of the relationship between the two groups, although his portrayal is often more formal and focused on the survival of the Pilgrims.
However, Bradford does not describe the feast itself in the same level of detail as Winslow. While he acknowledges that the Pilgrims had a successful harvest and invited the Wampanoag to celebrate, he does not provide specific descriptions of the foods, the number of people present, or the nature of the interactions during the feast. This gap in the historical record leaves room for interpretation, and over time, historians have had to rely on other sources and analysis to fill in the details.
3. The Wampanoag Perspective
While the Pilgrim accounts provide much of the narrative about the first Thanksgiving, it is essential to also consider the perspective of the Wampanoag people. The Wampanoag were not a monolithic group, and their experiences with the Pilgrims varied depending on the circumstances and time period. The primary sources from the Wampanoag perspective are scarce, and much of the information about their side of the story comes from oral traditions and later writings from Native American historians and scholars.
The Wampanoag oral tradition offers a different perspective on the Thanksgiving feast. Some Native American scholars suggest that while the first Thanksgiving may have been a peaceful gathering, it was also a strategic alliance between the Pilgrims and the Wampanoag. Chief Massasoit may have seen the gathering as an opportunity to strengthen ties with the newcomers, particularly since the Wampanoag were facing pressures from other tribes in the region. This interpretation suggests that the feast was not purely a celebration of harmony, but rather a pragmatic political and cultural exchange.
In addition, the Wampanoag people likely had their own reasons for participating in the feast, including the desire for peace and protection from other, more aggressive tribes. While the Pilgrims later viewed the event through a lens of gratitude and friendship, the Wampanoag likely saw it through a more complex lens of diplomacy, survival, and strategy.
4. The Role of Native American Oral Traditions
Native American oral traditions play an important role in understanding the historical context of the first Thanksgiving. Unlike the Pilgrim accounts, which were written down, much of the history of the Wampanoag and other Native American tribes was passed down through storytelling. These oral histories, preserved in the form of myths, legends, and teachings, provide valuable insights into how Native American peoples experienced their interactions with European settlers.
Oral traditions often present a different narrative than the one found in colonial-era written sources. For example, some Native American stories describe the arrival of European settlers in terms of disruption, disease, and loss, which contrasts sharply with the more celebratory tone of the Pilgrim accounts. Native American oral traditions also emphasize the long-term consequences of European colonization, including the displacement of Indigenous peoples, the spread of diseases, and the breakdown of traditional ways of life.
These oral histories, while not direct accounts of the first Thanksgiving itself, offer important context for understanding the complex relationship between Native Americans and European settlers in the early years of colonization.
The Legacy of the First Thanksgiving: Myths, Interpretations, and Controversies
Over time, the first Thanksgiving has been mythologized and interpreted in various ways, and the historical narrative surrounding the event has been influenced by cultural and political shifts. In the 19th century, as the United States sought to establish a cohesive national identity, the story of the Pilgrims and the Wampanoag was framed as a symbol of unity and harmony. This version of the first Thanksgiving emphasized the peaceful coexistence between the settlers and the Native Americans, portraying the event as a moment of cultural understanding and cooperation.
However, in recent decades, historians and Native American scholars have critiqued this narrative, pointing out that the relationship between the Pilgrims and the Wampanoag was far more complicated. While the first Thanksgiving may have been a peaceful gathering, it was also part of a larger historical context of colonization, land dispossession, and violence against Indigenous peoples. The years following the first Thanksgiving saw the Wampanoag lose much of their land and autonomy, as the Pilgrims and later settlers expanded their colonies.
For many Native Americans, Thanksgiving is a reminder of the long history of displacement and injustice experienced by Indigenous peoples. Some Native American groups observe the day as a “National Day of Mourning,” reflecting on the historical trauma caused by European colonization. This alternative perspective challenges the celebratory tone of mainstream Thanksgiving celebrations and invites a more critical examination of the holiday’s historical roots.
Conclusion
The story of the first Thanksgiving, as we know it, is shaped by a combination of historical accounts, oral traditions, and evolving cultural interpretations. Through the writings of Edward Winslow, William Bradford, and other early colonists, we gain a glimpse into the events surrounding the feast in 1621. However, the Wampanoag perspective and Native American oral histories provide a different context, highlighting the complexity of the relationship between Indigenous peoples and European settlers.
While the first Thanksgiving is often remembered as a moment of peace and cooperation, it is important to recognize that the legacy of this event is much more nuanced. By examining the sources, understanding the cultural contexts, and acknowledging the diverse perspectives surrounding Thanksgiving, we can gain a more comprehensive understanding of this pivotal moment in American history. The first Thanksgiving, like the holiday itself, continues to evolve as we reflect on its meaning in contemporary society and its significance for both Indigenous peoples and the broader American community.
Related topics:
Where to Watch the Thanksgiving Day Parade