Thanksgiving in the United States is a time of gratitude, celebration, and family gatherings. For many Americans, it represents a moment to reflect on the blessings of the year and spend time with loved ones around a festive meal. While Thanksgiving is primarily rooted in a blend of Native American, Pilgrim, and broader American cultural history, the Jewish community in America has embraced the holiday in its own unique way. Through the lens of Jewish tradition, Thanksgiving offers an opportunity to blend cultural values, religious practices, and the universal human experience of giving thanks.
This article will explore the various ways in which Jewish people celebrate Thanksgiving, highlighting the religious, cultural, and familial aspects of the holiday, while also reflecting on the broader context of Jewish history and identity in the United States.
The Origins of Thanksgiving and Its Appeal to Jewish Americans
Thanksgiving as we know it today traces its origins to the early 17th century, when English Pilgrims and Wampanoag Native Americans came together to celebrate a successful harvest. Over the centuries, the holiday evolved into a national day of thanks for the United States, officially declared by President Abraham Lincoln in 1863. For Jews in America, the Thanksgiving holiday has become a day to celebrate not just the American experience but also their own rich heritage and history.
For Jewish families, Thanksgiving offers an important opportunity to reflect on themes central to Jewish thought—gratitude, community, and the acknowledgment of divine providence. While it is not a Jewish religious holiday, its emphasis on giving thanks aligns with core Jewish values. Jewish teachings frequently emphasize the importance of expressing gratitude, both to God and to others, and Thanksgiving provides a moment for Jewish Americans to embody this principle in a culturally significant and universally recognized way.
Moreover, the Thanksgiving holiday holds particular resonance for Jewish immigrants who arrived in the United States in waves, especially during the 19th and early 20th centuries. For these families, the day of thanksgiving became a time to celebrate their new life in America, reflecting the values of freedom, opportunity, and religious liberty that many had sought when they left their homelands. Thanksgiving provided a sense of belonging in the wider American community, even as Jews maintained strong ties to their own customs and traditions.
Family Gatherings and the Thanksgiving Feast
For most Jewish families, Thanksgiving is a time for family reunions and shared meals. The traditional Thanksgiving meal—roast turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, cranberry sauce, and pumpkin pie—often takes center stage at these gatherings. However, the Jewish community has a long history of adapting food traditions to reflect its unique cultural and religious practices. As such, Thanksgiving meals in Jewish households might feature a blend of classic American dishes and Jewish culinary influences.
The Role of Food in Jewish Thanksgiving Celebrations
While the main dish at most Thanksgiving tables is turkey, Jewish families may also include other traditional Jewish foods. For instance, challah, the sweet, braided bread commonly eaten at Shabbat and Jewish holidays, may make an appearance on the Thanksgiving table. Matzah ball soup, a Jewish staple, is another dish that is sometimes served, providing a comforting and familiar taste for Jewish families. Additionally, kugel (a sweet or savory noodle pudding) might be included, as well as tzimmes (a sweet carrot and yam stew), which are traditional Ashkenazi Jewish dishes.
For some families, Thanksgiving is a time to make sure that kosher laws are observed. Kosher laws dictate the types of foods that are allowed, how food should be prepared, and how it should be consumed. For observant Jewish families, this might mean ensuring that the turkey is kosher and that all ingredients are permissible according to Jewish dietary laws (kashrut). This might require planning ahead, especially if the family is hosting a large gathering or inviting guests who are not Jewish.
In addition to the typical dishes, some Jewish families use Thanksgiving as an opportunity to showcase regional foods from their specific Jewish ancestry. For example, Sephardic Jewish families, who trace their roots to Spain and North Africa, might serve dishes such as couscous or lamb tagine alongside more typical Thanksgiving fare. This infusion of cultural diversity helps to personalize the celebration and reflect the wide-ranging Jewish diaspora.
Prayer, Blessings, and Religious Reflection
Though Thanksgiving is not a religious holiday in the Jewish calendar, it is a time when Jewish Americans often turn to their religious traditions to mark the occasion. For observant Jews, the holiday can serve as a way to incorporate gratitude into their daily prayers, such as the Shehechiyanu, a blessing traditionally recited on special occasions to give thanks for reaching a momentous occasion. Many Jewish families also recite prayers of thanksgiving before the meal, as they would on any other festive occasion.
The prayer Modeh Ani (“I thank You”) is one of the central prayers in the Jewish morning liturgy and is a reflection of gratitude to God for the gift of life. In some Jewish households, this prayer or other prayers of thanks might be recited as part of the Thanksgiving celebration. Additionally, Jewish people may recite the Birkat Hamazon (Grace After Meals) following their meal, which is an ancient Jewish prayer of thanks for the sustenance provided by God.
Some Jewish families have also adapted the concept of the Seder, the ritual meal celebrated during Passover, to the Thanksgiving meal. While it is not traditional, it is not uncommon for Jewish families to have a “Thanksgiving Seder,” where the traditional four questions asked during the Passover Seder are adapted to reflect on themes of Thanksgiving. This can include asking questions such as “What are we thankful for this year?” or “How can we show gratitude to God and to others?”
In these ways, Jewish people integrate their religious customs into the Thanksgiving celebration, demonstrating that the act of giving thanks is deeply embedded in Jewish spiritual practice.
Social Justice and Charity on Thanksgiving
For many Jewish families, Thanksgiving is not just a time to give thanks, but also a time to give back to the community. The Jewish tradition of tzedakah, or charity, is an important component of the Thanksgiving celebration for many Jewish Americans. Tzedakah is a core value in Jewish life, and it is understood not merely as charity but as a moral obligation to help those in need. On Thanksgiving, Jewish families may volunteer at food banks, donate to charities, or organize community events to ensure that others are able to enjoy a holiday meal.
This practice of giving back aligns with Thanksgiving’s broader theme of gratitude. For Jewish Americans, it serves as a reminder that the blessings of the holiday should be shared with those who are less fortunate. Jewish community centers, synagogues, and other organizations often host special events during Thanksgiving, such as communal meals for the homeless or food drives to support local families in need. This aspect of Thanksgiving reflects Jewish values of compassion, social justice, and solidarity with the most vulnerable members of society.
Thanksgiving and Jewish Identity
The way in which Jews celebrate Thanksgiving also reflects the evolving nature of Jewish identity in America. For American Jews, Thanksgiving offers a space to balance their Jewish identity with their American identity. The celebration of Thanksgiving, a national holiday, can help Jewish families feel more connected to the broader American society while simultaneously holding on to their own traditions and customs.
In fact, some Jewish Americans see Thanksgiving as an opportunity to share their Jewish culture with others, particularly in diverse, interfaith families. For Jewish families with non-Jewish spouses or relatives, Thanksgiving may be a way to bridge cultural gaps and foster a sense of unity across different backgrounds. The shared values of family, gratitude, and community provide common ground for Jews and non-Jews alike to come together in celebration.
However, Thanksgiving also raises some complex questions for Jews, particularly regarding the historical context of the holiday. The relationship between early European settlers and Native American tribes is fraught with a history of displacement, colonialism, and violence. For some Jewish people, especially those from Indigenous backgrounds, this history may cause them to question the celebration of Thanksgiving. There is ongoing discussion within Jewish communities about how to balance participation in the holiday with an awareness of its broader implications.
Conclusion: A Day of Gratitude, Unity, and Reflection
Thanksgiving holds a special place in the hearts of Jewish Americans. Although it is not a religious holiday, it has been embraced by Jewish communities as a time for reflection, celebration, and, most importantly, gratitude. For Jews, Thanksgiving offers a unique opportunity to blend Jewish customs and values with the broader American cultural experience.
Through family meals, prayers of thanks, acts of charity, and communal gatherings, Jewish Americans celebrate Thanksgiving in ways that honor their heritage while also participating in a national moment of collective gratitude. The holiday serves as a reminder that, regardless of cultural or religious background, the act of giving thanks is a universal practice that transcends boundaries and connects us all to the blessings we enjoy.
In the end, Thanksgiving is not just about a meal; it is about remembering the importance of community, acknowledging the blessings in our lives, and sharing those blessings with others. For Jewish Americans, this means reflecting on both their Jewish and American identities, celebrating the values that bind them together, and looking for ways to make the world a better place for all.
Related topics:
What to Take to Thanksgiving Dinner as a Guest